Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Deedi Brown's avatar

All things have a season. Hang in there! You are taking care of you!!

Expand full comment
Tom's avatar

I'm inclined to agree with you about the slightly unsatisfying nature of "Guard Your Daughters". The book is well written and entertaining, and the five Harvey sisters are all very interesting and attractive characters, but you have the sense that you're reading the low-fat version of what the novel could have been.

The most plausible backstory I could come up with to explain the parents' behaviour is that the family was living in London during the Blitz back in 1940, and mater and pater became so concerned for their daughters' welfare that they bought that large, vacant home out in the comparative safety of the English countryside, even though it cost more than they could really afford. I can imagine the mother having been so rattled by the sound of German aeroplanes overhead and the blast of falling bombs while living in London that she demanded a life of complete peace and quiet, even though her daughters had to pay such a heavy price for it that you wonder if Diana Tutton fully understood the nature of the sacrifice the girls were called upon to make for the sake of their mother. Or would her author's attitude to the sisters have been, "Suck it up, buttercup!"

I appreciate the link you left to Persephone Books with that editorial piece about the book and its author. Perhaps you'll recall the comment I sent you a while ago stating my wish that Diana Tutton had written a sequel to "Guard Your Daughters". I suggested the title "Guard Your Wives" and proposed that the new novel be set five years after the end of the first one, and that it describe how the five Harvey sisters are doing in the big, brand new outside world.

So, I couldn't help but be a little pleased with myself to read that Diana Tutton had actually written a sequel titled "Unguarded Moments" set in London seven years after "Guard Your Daughters", and that the plot includes a married Morgan with two children. But as the editorial says, alas, this sequel was never published. Quel dommage!

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts